This video about the world’s toughest job will have you in tears at the end! Watch it here!

You have to watch this! Sexy boy band surprises everyone, even Simon Cowell, on Britain’s Got Talent stage!

Thinus Ferreira

South Africa's pay TV in peril

2011-11-08 11:24
As an independent journalist unbeholden to any interests and having covered South Africa's television industry for the past 13 years, I feel the National Consumer Commission's uninformed demand that pay TV companies in South Africa do a so-called "unbundling" of the TV channels they offer should be of major concern to the industry, consumers and viewers.

This misguided demand will not be in the best interest of the average consumer or TV viewer.

The National Consumer Commission clearly has no idea of the complex and intricate eco-system that makes something like pay TV possible and viable in the first place.

Why the National Consumer Commission wants to be demonstratively prescriptive of the pay TV industry which is actually governed by the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (Icasa) as the regulator for the country's television industry, is anyone's guess.

For the average consumer, the beautiful fantasy of picking the separate TV channels you want, and letting each of the 3.7 million other pay TV subscribers in South Africa each pick the channels they want, is of course a wonderful, enticing, desirable and lofty idea.

It'll cost you way more

Why not force the big companies who must surely be overcharging us, to give me just the TV channels I want? Why do I get The Hamster Network (when all that they ever do is sleep) when all I really want is the Badminton Channel? What the consumer doesn't know – and clearly also not the National Consumer Commission – is that a so-called "a la carte" approach will end up costing the consumer and you as the pay TV subscriber more, not less.

Even if you pick just a few TV channels, it will end up costing you more. Way more.

While pay TV is expensive and has a price tier depending on the number of premium channels you subscribe to, it's not a super deluxe service. Because of an economy of scale, pay television is not the sole preserve of those with infinity pools and Bentleys and the polo preppy champagne crowd.

But that is what pay TV will be turned into if the National Consumer Commission's busybody orders are enforced.

Also gone will be The Hamster Network and the Badminton Channel – basically any TV channel that's not incredibly popular. Because, although you might really like The Knitting Network, the 10 potential subscribers who might desperately want that channel, won't be enough of an incentive for a commercially-run entity to include and offer that channel.

Less choice; more cost. Isn't a theme park more fun when it doesn't charge per ride but only entry? You can potentially ride on a selection but if you wish, you can just experience the roller-coaster. It's the economy of scale that makes the existence of the theme park possible. Pay per ride and the rollercoaster would be way more expensive, the teacups would limp along and the snake show would disappear because there's not enough general interest.

Delicate eco-system

In reality the pay TV model is an intricate and delicate eco-system of interdependent parts. Pay TV operators like MultiChoice and TopTV have to intricately balance premium TV content as value propositions - the challenge being to bring TV channels to viewers by striking deals with content providers where the effort and the cost of doing that outweighs the cost.

If they can't make money out of it to sustain it, they're not going to do it. Less news, less documentaries, less kids channels, less specialist programming and a leaner TV channel diet centred mostly around what's lucrative: populist sport, soaps and movies with commercials. 

Nothing is wrong with South Africa's pay TV industry except for their below average customer service levels. The National Consumer Commission would really be of service to ordinary consumers looking at real problems rather than enforcing new rules that will have unintended consequences. The unneccessary tampering is not serving consumers.

Will the Commission next order newspapers and magazines to sell their stories individually? In essence a newspaper or magazine is also "bundling" stories and adverts and supplements together to create one product that has enough different parts to make it enticing enough to consumers to buy and make a profit. You might not read every single story in a newspaper, but you bought it.

Step back

The National Consumer Commission should step back and leave pay TV operators to free market forces under the regulation of Icasa which they already fall under, and which has a prescribed code for pay television and strict licensing regulations governing the sector.

How will it be better for the consumer and TV viewer in South Africa if overseas investors, channel suppliers and distributors become scared or no longer want to bring their product here because our pay TV model is forced by silly rules to operate differently than the rest of the world?

If this change goes forward, it is not going to be for the better of the average consumer.

Thinus Ferreira is an independent TV critic and journalist covering South Africa's television industry. Read his blog here. publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Add your comment
Comment 0 characters remaining

Recent News

It's extremely sad, distressing, disappointing and scandalous that SABC1 and the production company are not pulling the reality show Tropika Island of Treasure 5 with the late model Reeva Steenkamp. Read this review

It's not illegal, but surely it's not right for MTV to be advertising vodka when the majority of its audience is under 18 years of age? Read this review

inside channel 24

Now Showing at the Movies

Where is it showing...
OR find out what's on where...


More Gossip

This Week's Top Free Song

Never Been Better feat Tsholo


Download Now » LuKE9ine (whose real name is Lukonde Mwila) is a young rapper from Lusaka, currently based in South Africa who has made the decision to pursue the journey of recording rap music that glorifies the Lord.
Get More Free Music »

Jobs - Find your dream job

Property - Find a new home

Travel - Look, Book, Go!

Escape winter, head to Mauritius

Escape winter by spending 7 nights in Mauritius' tropical bliss from R13 215 per person sharing. Includes return flights, airport transfers and accommodation.Book now! - shop online today

Sony BDP-S1100 Smart Blu-Ray Player now R699

This smart player supports multiple playback options including Blu-ray movies, DVD's, CD's and media files via USB. Plus stream movies, music and catch-up TV through the Sony entertainment network. Buy now!

DVDs under R100

Catch these epic blockbusters for under R100. Featured titles include, Frozen, Despicable Me2, About Time, The Animal Communicator and many more. Shop now!

DStv HD PVR Decoder now R949

The DStv HD PVR Decoder has further revolutionised the television experience with lifelike viewing, sharper images, more vibrant colours and precision picture quality. Now R949, save R550. Offer valid while stocks last. Shop now!

The Real Meal Revolution

The goal of The Real Meal Revolution is to change your life by teaching you how to take charge of your weight and your health through the way you eat. Order now! #1 selling product

gobii eReader + FREE wall charger and leatherette cover now R599, save R340. Offer valid while stocks last. Shop now!
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.