Lawyer Mark Geragos - working for his client Thaer Kamal - has reportedly contacted the Mean Girls actress' legal representative Shawn Holley claiming to have video evidence of Lindsay striking Thaer.
The footage also shows her getting out of the driver's side of the car, wobbling and getting into the passenger seat, where the passenger then takes over the wheel.
However, sources who were at the scene at the time have told TMZ.com it did not happen.
His lawyer has made it clear he has not yet gone to police and had an interview, and gave Lindsay's camp until Thursday to pay - it is not known if she has.
Thaer also reportedly told people at the scene he was not injured but changed his mind when he heard the troubled star was the one behind the wheel.
Lindsay hit out at the accusation she had "scraped" someone with her car last week on Twitter.
She said: "Scrape? This is all a complete lie. I've been at community service. Last night, I attempted to wish a friend happy birthday, which I didn't even get to do because I was freaked out by all of the paparazzi. These false accusations are absurd."
24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.
Taraji P Henson loves shopping at discount store Target but is finding it increasingly more difficult because of the attention she receives. Read More »
Elizabeth Hurley revealed she only keeps a bottle of vodka and eye masks in her fridge in her London home. Read More »
New local act.
Our epic night.
East RandUbuntuR30 000 - R35 000 Per Month
GautengUBUNTUR7 000 - R10 000 Per Month
Western CapeUbuntu recruitmentR15 000 - R20 000 Per Month
Apartments / FlatsR 12 500 000
HousesR 1 685 000
HousesR 2 990 000