Check out our Q&A with Idris Elba about losing his father, getting lost in a character and Arsenal!

Kylie Jenner said 'yes' when asked if she'd marry Tyga, despite speculation they had split

ASA dismisses anti-Israel ad on 5FM

2011-07-07 15:35
Cape Town - The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) has dismissed complaints against a radio commercial for SA Artists Against Apartheid broadcast on radio station 5FM.

The commercial features the voice of Dave Randall, guitarist of the dance group Faithless.

He says: "Hi, I’m Dave Randall from Faithless. Twenty years ago I would not have played in apartheid South Africa, today I refuse to play in Israel.

"Be on the right side of history. Don’t entertain apartheid. Join the international boycott of Israel. I support"

The SA Jewish Board of Deputies and other consumers complained, among other things, that the commercial was unclear as to the identity of the advertiser, and was untrue and not supported by any evidence to verify the implied claim that Israel was an apartheid state.

Truth and facts

Another complaint was that the band compared Israel to an apartheid state and that this was factually incorrect and irresponsible.

The ASA ruled that it was apparent Randall was voicing support for a cause known as SA Artists Against Apartheid, and that the advertising appeared at the instance of that organisation or cause.

It was also clear from the commercial that it was the opinion of Randall. He said, among other things, “I would not have played... ”, “Today I refuse... ”, and “I support...”

While he might very well be drawing a possible analogy between apartheid South Africa and Israel, he was clearly doing so in his capacity and as the face for the “artists against apartheid” cause.

The commercial therefore communicated an opinion, not a fact, and as such should not be held to the same criteria for substantiation as general, efficacy or otherwise claims that were communicated as facts.

Matter of opinion

The commercial was clearly expressing a personal view shared not only by Randall, but also by SA Artists Against Apartheid.

"It goes without saying that the call for support is aimed at like-minded people, who share this view. This is significant in that the commercial is clearly aimed at generating discussion amid the controversy.

"With this in mind, it stands to reason that the people who are likely to be offended by this commercial are likely to hold the view that the current situation and action in Israel is justifiable.

"It is not for the Directorate to proclaim as to which political ideals or actions are justifiable, or to base this decision on whether or not the actions in Israel are legitimate would be a fallacy."

Thus, the complaints were dismissed.
Read more on:    asa  |  israel  |  media publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Recent News

Nearly a hundred gamers descended on the MWEB MCave in Cape Town for Gigabyte's unofficial launch party for the newly-released Battlefront game from Electronic Arts. Read More »

Prince Harry is set to play in the sixth Sentebale Royal Salute Polo Cup held for the first time in South Africa. Read More »

inside channel 24

There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.