Publications
Partners
- The BCCSA dismissed complaints against eNCA and Lindsay Dentlinger over the mask saga.
- Dentlinger asked a black politician to put on a mask during an interview, but allegedly did not do the same when interviewing a white politician.
- The BCCSA found there was no indication that Dentlinger's request advocated racial bias.
The Broadcasting Complaints Commission of South Africa (BCCSA) dismissed complaints against eNCA and its reporter, Lindsay Dentlinger, in relation to the mask-wearing saga.
Dentlinger was accused of showing racial bias after video clips emerged of her conducting interviews outside Parliament during the budget speech.
News24 previously reported she had interviewed FF Plus leader Pieter Groenewald, who was not wearing a mask. When she turned to interview UDM deputy president Nqabayomzi Kwankwa, she asked him to keep on his mask.
Dentlinger has denied the claims, while her employer, eNCA, said the inconsistent behaviour regarding Covid-19 protocols during live interviews was not racially motivated.
FACT CHECK | eNCA's Lindsay Dentlinger: We analysed the video that caused racist outcry - and 24 other interviews
It was also reported that the SA Human Rights Commission would be investigating the incident. The BCCSA received dozens of complaints, but only 11 of the complaints met the necessary criteria.
One of the complainants was the UDM.
In a statement on Friday, eNCA announced that it had received the BCCSA judgment and the complaints had been dismissed.
According to eNCA, the BCCSA found:
- There was no indication the reporter's request to Kwankwa to keep his mask on advocated hatred based on race against black people.
- While it was clear the broadcast caused offence, as evidenced by the complaints before the BCCSA, the broadcaster did not contravene clause 10.3 of the code (advocates hatred that is based on race, ethnicity, gender or religion and which constitutes incitement to cause harm.)
- The BCCSA recognises past injustices, which have led to sensitivity towards matters that involve race, but the facts of this matter do not justify an inference of the advocacy of hatred against black people.
- After considering all the facts, it was found that eNCA did not contravene the code. The complaints are accordingly not upheld.
Reacting to the findings, the managing director of eNCA, Norman Munzhelele, said that, as a responsible broadcaster, eNCA is governed by the BCCSA's code of conduct and are satisfied with the judgment.
"eNCA understands how our reporter's coverage created a space for general public conjecture and are sorry that her behaviour was perceived to be racist and offended viewers," Munzhelele said.
"However, we reiterate that our internal investigation found, like the BCCSA did, that her conduct was not racially motivated. We remain committed to providing fair and balanced news, irrespective of race, colour or creed."
