Miley Cyrus VS Janet Jackson: Whose nipple caused the most outrage?

2015-09-01 10:21

(Warning: This article contains nipple)

New York - Janet Jackson exposed a breast on national television a decade ago, and it sparked national outrage. Miley Cyrus' flash barely caused a shrug.

Cyrus' exposure came near the end of Sunday's MTV Video Music Awards. She peeked her head out from behind a black curtain that covered up all but her head, then the curtain slipped to briefly reveal a bare breast.

"What's happening?" said the singer, Sunday's show host. "Oh, sorry. My tit's out."

MTV said it cut the unexpected glimpse of flesh for reruns of its annual televised party.

By the next morning, it wasn't even watercooler fodder. Kanye West's rambling acceptance of a career achievement award and declaration of his 2020 presidential candidacy was the hot topic on a programme known more for outlandish pop culture moments than awards.

It was a far different venue and era when Jackson's wardrobe malfunction during the 2004 Super Bowl halftime show, aided by Justin Timberlake, provoked 1.4 million complaints to the Federal Communications Commission. The FCC fined CBS $550 000, and the case dragged through the courts until 2012, when that verdict was overturned.

The FCC had no immediate count on any Cyrus complaints on Monday, and it wouldn't matter much anyway because the commission has no jurisdiction over cable or satellite networks.

(Photo: Getty Images)

Sheer numbers limited Cyrus' exposure, even if the curtain didn't. The 2004 Super Bowl was seen by an estimated 86 million viewers. The Nielsen ratings company said the Video Music Awards was seen by 9.8 million people.

Entertainment journalist Alicia Quarles, former global entertainment editor for The Associated Press, said the shock factor has worn off.

"You can go online and see Rihanna's nipples on her Instagram account," Quarles said. "There's nothing exciting about it anymore."

Similarly, not much work is required for a glimpse of Cyrus' bare breasts. The 22-year-old former child star has posed for a handful of nude or topless magazine portraits in the past few years.

Since finding one of those risque moments, like when Cyrus twerked with Robin Thicke during the 2013 programme, is the whole point of the VMAs, a flash couldn't have been considered much of a surprise.

Condemnation of the incident from the Parents Television Council immediately afterward took on a weary, almost defeatist tone. PTC President Tim Winter said he wasn't surprised Cyrus exposed herself.

"About as surprised as we'll be if the sun rises in the east tomorrow morning," he said. publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.