Elton John: Stop segregating HIV inmates

2012-09-18 15:59
Washington - The US states of Alabama and South Carolina discriminate against HIV-positive prisoners by separating them from others and excluding them from early release programmes, claims Elton John.

Infected inmates also face hurdles accessing treatment they need to manage their disease and stop it from progressing, the British celebrity alleged in an opinion piece published in the Washington Post.

"In the 80s, people infected with the Aids virus faced horrendous, daily discrimination and injustice," John wrote. "Today, Alabama and South Carolina are blatantly and dangerously discriminating against HIV-positive prisoners."

'HIV is no longer a death sentence'

John is the founder of the Elton John AIDS Foundation and the author of Love is The Cure: On Life, Loss and the End of AIDS.

While in Alabama, prisoners infected with HIV are forced to wear white armbands, their counterparts in South Carolina are housed in maximum security facilities alongside death row convicts, according to John.

"Of course, prisoners waive certain rights when they break the law," John wrote. "But HIV is no longer a death sentence; simply having the virus merits neither cruel and unusual punishment nor the denial of opportunities to earn one's way back into society."

Policies are justfied

John said authorities in the two Southern states insist their policies are justified by the need to provide medical care to such inmates and prevent the spread of the virus, two points he called "excuses lacking evidence".

"By depriving HIV-positive prisoners of equal treatment, Alabama and South Carolina promote fear, prejudice and even violence against them."

John's piece coincided with opening arguments in a class-action lawsuit filed by the American Civil Liberties Union aimed at ending Alabama's segregation of prisoners with HIV.

Margaret Winter, associate director of ACLU's National Prison Project, said: "The mere fact that a person has HIV does not make him a threat to anyone and there is no legitimate reason whatsoever to categorically segregate prisoners with HIV."


  • Billy - 2012-09-18 16:12

    what?! has this guy lost the plot?

  • Bob.Cee123 - 2012-09-18 16:25

    Other variables such as inevitable sexual interaction between inmates, whether forced or consenting, should be considered as well. If there is no 100% guarantee that rape or other forms of sexual assault cannot be completely prevented, then the provision of condoms is simply not enough to stop the spread. I don't fully support the separation, but it's definitely not as clear cut as Elton John makes it seem. At least the separation aspect of it. It is a whole other issue that the HIV positive inmates are not being granted access to suitable treatment and are being 'branded' with the armbands and excluded from opportunities for early release. That is just despicable.

  • mack.myburgh - 2012-09-18 16:32

    O Reggie piss off !

  • ndumiso.mncwango - 2012-09-18 16:43

    They are pretending they don't know that prisoners rape each other

  • jeremy002 - 2012-09-18 16:57

    In sympathy with their 'plight', perhaps the little guy should ask to be incarcerated with these HIV positive inmates and get a taste of what it's like to be jumped from behind and get infected by one of them. I think the non HIV positive inmates have a right to protection. The alternative could be a death sentence.

  • morgaenart.farto - 2012-09-18 17:26

    Oh bugger!

  • klaas.waarzegger.7 - 2012-09-18 17:50

    The queen of England has spoken!

  • pages:
  • 1