SABC3 cited for Eucharist cannibal claim

2012-12-20 11:02

Johannesburg - An SABC3 programme likening the Christian Eucharist to cannibalism included a fundamental error, a tribunal of the Broadcasting Complaints Commission has found.

"The Eucharist is of particular importance to Christians and it is in the public interest that misinformation in this regard not be broadcast," said the tribunal.

A broadcast aired in October of the programme Shoreline discussed archaeological evidence for cannibalism.

Presenter Gavin Whitelaw said: "Eating people might be a way of gaining access to some special element, some special essence of the victims. Christians for example eat the blood and the body of Christ so they can absorb some of his purity and godliness."

'No intention to denigrate Christianity'

Christian viewers complained that this statement misrepresented the truth.

In response, SABC3 compliance and regulatory manager Fakir Hassan said complainants were taking the statement "very literally".

"It is obvious that Christians do not and never have literally eaten the blood and body of Christ, although Catholics hold to the idea of transubstantiation, in which bread and wine symbolically become flesh and blood at the time of Communion," he said.

Instead, consuming the "body" and "blood" of Jesus was a symbolic act and a ritual moment of deep significance.

"It is in this context that the presenter made the statement."

SABC3 acknowledged the statement made no clear reference to symbolism and in this may have caused offence.

In the public interest

There was no intention to denigrate Christianity or incite any kind of violence against Christians.

However, the comments were edited to ensure that rebroadcasts did not contain the statement.

In its evaluation, the tribunal found that the programme had erred in its presentation of religion, and this was in the public interest.

However, the programme was typically informative in nature, and SABC3 had immediately re-edited the programme for future broadcasts to rectify the error.

As a result, it found that a reprimand would suffice and a broadcast rectifying the error would not be necessary.

The judgment was released on Tuesday and distributed to the media on Thursday.

The case was heard last month.

Comments

  • chaze.damonze - 2012-12-20 11:20

    Lol!

  • squeegee.pilot - 2012-12-20 11:22

    Fortunately the SABC has no credibility.

  • gary.maggz - 2012-12-20 11:30

    I used to go to a catholic church but left after they refused to entertain my idea of having a nice selection of party dips to go with the communion...and a bowl of sangria punch to wash it down. Boring bunch of gits!!

  • emma.jay.1466 - 2012-12-20 11:47

    Scientific Proof that SA education has DECLINED. Lmao!

  • georg.laing - 2012-12-20 12:09

    And... They're STILL wrong. Catholics believe the bread and wine LITERALLY become the Body and Blood of Christ.

      Bob.Cee123 - 2012-12-20 12:23

      “The easy confidence with which I know another man's religion is folly teaches me to suspect that my own is also.” ? Mark Twain

      georg.laing - 2012-12-20 18:17

      That would have been a profound insight, but for the fact that people convert and revert all the time.

  • Nicole Soccer-Babe Take - 2012-12-20 12:11

    whose a biggest looser here?

  • Raymon - 2012-12-20 13:55

    All you atheist haters can do is spread hatred. I am a proud born again Christian. Sticks and stones people.... Merry Christmas !!!

      Bob.Cee123 - 2012-12-20 14:27

      Merry Mithramas to you too mate

  • willem.dehaan.94 - 2012-12-20 15:14

    I wonder what the comments would have been if the misinformation was about any aspect of Islam?

  • pages:
  • 1